THE DESOLATION OF SMAUG

SYOPSIS –The quest to the Misty Mountain continues as a looming danger begins to make its presence felt. Don’t you just hate it when someone pontificates needlessly and makes every spurious fallacious and redundant attempt to avoid arriving at a clear concise undiluted noncomplex simplistic conclusion? Or rather don’t you hate it when someone won’t just get to the point; this was the crux of my problem with the first instalment of this trilogy (out before this blog started). Did even the most diehard Tolkien fan think we needed the song about putting Bilbo’s dishes away? In this second instalment things move much more quickly so that the long run time does not feel quite so drawn out. It helps that we get thrown right into the action after only a brief flashback (that actually serves a purpose). Because the pace feels much faster it’s easier to put up with exposition heavy scenes where we have to hear about what someone’s ancestor did that will somehow tie in later. This is good because though there is plenty of action there is also plenty of exposition and moody brooding to get through. Another reason I feel Desolation works better than an Unexpected Journey is the dwarves’ journey and the wider looming threat tie into each other better, you can see how one affects the other and, as a result, the film feels more fluid and complete. Director Peter Jackson also seems less afraid of straying from the source text when it is more pragmatic to do so for the sake of the film. Although this might provoke an outcry from the fan base it is, on the whole,better for the story. Martin Freeman continues to give a strong performance as Bilbo capturing the strength and vulnerability of the character. Richard Armitage as Thorin also stands out as a darker side begins to come to the front of his character. Though not appearing until near the film’s climax Smaug (Benedict Cumberbatch) does not disappoint or detract from the hype he has received, the special effects working well with Cumberbatch’s vocal performance. The dwarves feel more like a group of individuals than simply a group of faceless non-entities. Not all of the new features are for the best; we get a generic love story that sticks out from the story by its crowbarred insertion. The ending of the film feels a bit slapdash – as if Jackson suddenly realised he needed to the characters from C to E and had to skip D. On the whole though this is a solid enjoyable film and sets up the final film in the trilogy FINAL VERDICT 8/10 Good special effects and strong writing combine to make the adventure come to life.

Read More

Unknown 01:33  No comment

FIFTH ESTATE

SYNOPSIS – The story of how Wikileaks came to prominence as an online superpower. You would need to have been living under a rock for the past couple of years to have not heard of Wikileaks. The controversial website has made it its mission to provide a platform for whistle-blowers in any industry and on any topic, and the man at the centre of all that controversy is Julian Assange. Obviously with such a highly divisive topic as this coming up with a cohesive film script could be rather problematic. Indeed Assange himself has already denounced the film as lies and propaganda and sent star Benedict Cumberbatch an email asking him not to take part. The filmmakers use Daniel Domscheit-Berg (Daniel Bruhl), the site’s former spokesperson, as our eyes and ears into the man and the movement. Right from the start we encounter the problem that has plagued films such as this through the ages - how to make the sight of people typing on keyboards exciting. The solution offered here is the visual metaphor of a large endless office - this isn’t entirely ineffective (though wasn’t this what everyone laughed at hackers for?) The imagery does, however, being used repeatedly throughout the film, grow rather tiresome and boring. The film tends to sag towards the middle after we get a montage of Wikileak’s greatest hits and there seems little to do but wait for the big one (the infamous leak of Afgahnistan war logs). To fill the middle gap we get Domscheit-Berg’s relationship troubles and debates on the ethics of the site that feel rather like filler. Now it has to be said that once we reach the endgame things pick up and interest levels rise again. The story of the Manning (the name of the Private who leaked the documents) leak could quite easily have taken most the film and, had this been the case, the film might have had better closure. Part of my dissatisfaction with the ending might stem from the director’s efforts to put an end to a story that is still very much on-going. Credit for saving the film from its plodding plot must go to its actor Bendidict Cumberbatch. Forced to play a complex contradictory character, Cumberbatch manages to capture both the awe Assange can instil whilst exactly showing his erratic darker side that drives a wedge between him and his only real friend. Bruhl, I feel, also deserves credit for his performance, his part may be that of observer, a guest in Julian’s mad world, but he breathes life into a character that otherwise might seem a little flat or dull. FINAL VERDICT 6/10 –Overall the film entertains but feels overawed by its subject matter. Perhaps when more time has passed a stronger attempt could be made.

Read More

Unknown 13:06  No comment